Tried some other fly patterns. I tried hairwing streamers, Kraft Fur minnows, etc. Just about everything caught fish, but some patterns made it much quicker and easier.
Microjigs and Kraft Fur Clousers were the top 2 patterns. Unweighted patterns just didn't get down close to the fish quickly enough even though the crappies would eventually come up to take them. I only tried a blue Clouser...not a color I use often, but it worked very well. I tried a variety of colors of microjigs, and all caught fish very well.
On 10/21, I caught at least 12 Crappies and 3 Green Sunfish.
On 10/22, I caught 21 Crappies and 3 Green Sunfish.
On both of these trips, I caught some black crappies along with the white crappies.
Heres some pics from these 2 days:
Blue Kraft Fur Clouser
Kraft Fur Minnow